How to Pick the Perfect Cruise (Without Losing Your Mind)

So, you’ve decided to set sail on a cruise. Congratulations! Now comes the hard part—picking the right cruise line. Because, believe me, not all cruises are created equal. Some are floating theme parks, some are fine-dining experiences at sea, and some are, well… let’s just say they’re best for those who like peace, quiet, and a 9 PM bedtime. Understanding how to choose a cruise can make all the difference.

Step 1: Where (and When) Are You Going?

Before you even start debating between waterslides and five-course meals, you need to figure out where you want to cruise. Some destinations will limit your cruise line choices. Want to explore the Norwegian fjords? That’s how we ended up on Holland America—I barely remember the ship, but I definitely remember the stunning scenery. If you have your heart set on a particular destination, make sure your dream cruise line actually goes there before you get too excited. Check out our guide on how to pick a destination.

Timing matters, too. Some cruise lines shift their ships to different regions throughout the year. Plus, traveling during spring break vs. September can drastically change your onboard experience. (Hint: If you don’t love crowds of over-sugared children, avoid peak holiday and summer months on family-friendly lines.) Making smart decisions on how to choose a cruise can avoid many pitfalls.

Step 2: Picking the Right Cruise Line for You

Once you’ve figured out where and when you’re going, it’s time to pick the right ship for your style. Here’s the lowdown on the big players:

Celebrity Cruises: Best Food, Fewer Thrills

• Who it’s for: The 50+ crowd, couples, and those who prefer a more refined experience over belly flop contests. If you opt for the Blu dining experience, it is well worth it.
• Onboard Vibes: Relaxed, elegant, and not exactly a playground. There are things to do, but not nearly as much as on Carnival or Royal Caribbean.
• Food: Hands down, the best food of all the major cruise lines. If your vacation priorities include gourmet dining, this is your winner.
• Activities: Fewer bells and whistles. If you want non-stop entertainment, look elsewhere.
• Book a Celebrity cruise here!

Princess Cruises: Like Celebrity, But With Carnival-Level Food

• Who it’s for: Also geared toward an older crowd, but a little more low-key than Celebrity.
• Onboard Vibes: Classic cruising with a focus on relaxation.
• Food: Good, but more on par with Carnival—not quite the fine dining experience of Celebrity.
• Activities: Similar to Celebrity—this isn’t the ship for adrenaline junkies.
• Book your next Princess adventure here!

Royal Caribbean: The Floating Adventure Park

• Who it’s for: Families, adventure seekers, and anyone who thinks a vacation should involve as many activities as possible.
• Onboard Vibes: Action-packed. Some ships feel like floating amusement parks, and that’s not a bad thing.
• Food: Look, you won’t starve, but it’s the weakest of the major cruise lines in our experience.
• Activities: This is where Royal Caribbean shines. Think rock climbing walls, FlowRider surf simulators, water slides, mini golf, arcades, and more. Some ships even run “kids sail free” promos, making them a great deal for families.
• Book your next Royal Holiday here!

Carnival Cruises: Family Fun on a Budget

• Who it’s for: Families, younger cruisers, and anyone who wants a lively atmosphere.
• Onboard Vibes: Fun, casual, and sometimes a bit of a party scene.
• Food: Better than Royal Caribbean, but not quite on Celebrity’s level.
• Activities: Tons to do! Some ships have trampoline parks, roller coasters, rope courses, water slides, and arcades. If you’re traveling with kids, they’ll never be bored. Learning how to choose a cruise with great activities can ensure an enjoyable trip.
• Book your Carnival family fun here!

Step 3: Make Your Choice & Get Ready to Set Sail

So, which cruise is right for you? If you’re all about fine dining and relaxation, Celebrity or Princess will be your best bet. If you need non-stop activities and family fun, go for Royal Caribbean or Carnival. And if your priority is the destination over the ship itself, check out other specialty lines like Viking River Cruises.

No matter what, you’re going to have an amazing time—just don’t forget to pack your stretchy pants. Cruise food portions don’t mess around. But first, you need to know how to choose a cruise that fits your needs.

Book your cruise here

Don’t forget to check out some of our other destinations.

Check out our article on Why Traveling With Kids Is Surprisingly Awesome.